Probing Dust in the Disk of a Growing Giant Planet

New research suggests that the circumplanetary disk surrounding the exoplanet PDS 70c contains a ring of dense dust, and the conditions within this ring may allow baby moons to form.

A Disk Within a Disk

The young star PDS 70 has become famous for its protoplanetary disk and its two growing giant planets, PDS 70b and PDS 70c. At least one of these planets is surrounded by a disk of its own; in 2019, researchers using the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) reported the first-ever observation of a circumplanetary disk around PDS 70c, and later observations with ALMA brought clearer views of this disk.

There’s still debate over the exact source of the emission detected by ALMA. Does this emission come from dust, and if so, how is the dust distributed? Is the disk optically thick or optically thin? Does the emission even come from dust, or could it instead be free–free emission from unbound electrons navigating a charged-particle maze?

Dust Diagnosis

Yuhito Shibaike (Kagoshima University) and collaborators recently examined the hypothesis that the emission from PDS 70c’s circumplanetary disk arises from dust distributed in an optically thick ring. To test this hypothesis, the team explored two possible dust distributions, which they call “drift” and “ring.” In the drift model, dust grains within the circumplanetary disk migrate inward toward the planet, leaving much of the disk optically thin. Modeling suggests that this migration is typical in protoplanetary disks, and it might be common in circumplanetary disks as well.

In the ring model, the dust grains are concentrated within an optically thick ring at a certain distance from the planet. Simulations suggest that the formation of this type of dust ring is feasible, arising from a localized increase in gas density, outflows, or other causes.

Shibaike and coauthors found that the ring model naturally reproduced the observed spectral energy distribution for a range of reasonable parameters. The drift model, on the other hand, required an unrealistically high dust-to-gas ratio for the material accreted onto the circumplanetary disk from the parent protoplanetary disk to reproduce the observed spectral index.

Future Prospects and Moon-Making Possibilities

This work demonstrated the feasibility of the dust-ring model, but it didn’t rule out a contribution due to free–free emission from unbound electrons, which has also been proposed to explain the disk’s appearance. The team noted that distinguishing between thermal dust emission and free–free emission is challenging with existing data, as the two sources produce spectral energy distributions with similar shapes.

Luckily, this likely won’t remain a mystery forever: the next-generation Very Large Array, which is anticipated to begin full science operations in the mid-2030s, should be able to resolve the location of the dust within the circumplanetary disk and illuminate the source of emission.

Finally, if the dust surrounding PDS 70c is concentrated within a ring, what does that mean for the possibility of moons forming within the disk? Shibaike and collaborators found that the conditions within the ring likely satisfy the requirements of both the streaming instability and the gravitational instability, which are required for dust grains to clump together and form the rocky building blocks of baby moons. Perhaps the PDS 70 system will one day be the site of not only a circumplanetary disk, but an exomoon as well!

Citation

“Interpreting ALMA Multiwavelength Continuum Observations of PDS 70 c: An Optically Thick Dust Ring in the Circumplanetary Disk,” Yuhito Shibaike et al 2026 ApJL 1006 L26. doi:10.3847/2041-8213/ae86f5