AAS Nova

First-Generation Stars Provide Better Fit than a Black Hole for Early-Universe Gas Clump

By on Features
Share:
Star formation in the early universe.
Artist’s impression of star formation during the very early universe. Forming from pristine gas, extremely massive stars coalesce to build the universe’s first galaxies. [Adolf Schaller for STScI]

An unusual clump of gas 450 million years after the Big Bang may contain stars hailing from the universe’s elusive first generation of stars. New research examines an alternative explanation involving an accreting black hole.

Meet Hebe

Hebe and GN-z11

Hebe is visible in the image on the left as a prominent blob of helium emission up and to the left from GN-z11, a luminous galaxy hosting an accreting supermassive black hole. On the right is an infrared image of the same region, in which Hebe is not visible. Click to enlarge. [Adapted from NASA, ESA, CSA, Ralf Crawford (STScI)]

Initially spotted in 2024, an early-universe gas clump nicknamed Hebe has now been identified as a possible hiding place of Population III (Pop III) stars — the universe’s first generation of stars. Pop III stars are thought to be massive and chemically pristine, containing only hydrogen, helium, and a whisper of lithium. This exciting hypothesis was prompted by the detection of recombination lines from helium, which could be ionized by the high-energy radiation of the first stars.

Before the community settles on this exciting explanation, however, the hypothesis must withstand all the tests astronomers can throw at it. In a recent research article, Junehyoung Jeon, Tae Bong Jeong, and Saiyang Zhang (The University of Texas at Austin) along with Volker Bromm (The University of Texas at Austin) attempted to explain Hebe’s properties in another way.

Considering Alternatives

Hebe glows with distinctive helium emission that requires a source of high-energy radiation. This radiation could be provided by a cluster of Pop III stars, but it could also, in theory, arise from an accreting supermassive black hole embedded within the gas clump.

predicted Pop III star mass in Hebe

Predicted total mass of Hebe’s Pop III stars as a function of the Lyman–Werner flux from the nearby galaxy GN-z11. Click to enlarge. [Jeon et al. 2026]

The authors used models to explore both possibilities. For the first scenario, in which the telltale helium emission is driven by a cluster of Pop III stars, the team calculated the maximum possible mass of the cluster, which sets how much high-energy radiation is produced. The cluster mass is moderated by high-energy radiation from another source: GN-z11, a starburst galaxy situated about 10,000 light-years from Hebe. For the second scenario, the team modeled the spectral energy distribution arising from a supermassive black hole — either a direct-collapse black hole or a primordial black hole — accreting pristine gas from the surrounding cloud.

Still a Leading Explanation

While the black hole scenario could, with reasonable black hole masses, gas densities, and accretion rates, reproduce individual flux measurements drawn from JWST observations, this hypothesis struggled to simultaneously match multiple measurements. The Pop III star cluster scenario, with a cluster mass of a few hundred thousand solar masses, provided the best fit to the JWST data.

modeled spectral energy distributions for Hebe based on the black hole or Pop III star hypotheses

Modeled spectral energy distributions (lines) and predicted line flux densities (open symbols) for the accreting black hole, Pop III star, and Pop II (second-generation) star hypotheses. The observed JWST line fluxes are shown as filled circles. Click to enlarge. [Jeon et al. 2026]

As a final test, the team introduced a third possibility involving a population of second-generation stars, which are more chemically enriched than Pop III stars. While this model fit well, the number of stars necessary to match the data — roughly 10 million — would produce a stellar continuum detectable (but so far not seen) by JWST.

While a cluster of Pop III stars is still the leading explanation for Hebe’s properties, the team noted that the Pop III star and black hole hypotheses aren’t mutually exclusive; Hebe could very well harbor a primordial black hole and a smattering of Pop III stars. Regardless of what powers its characteristic helium emission, Hebe offers an enticing glimpse into the early universe, and more work is needed to understand this intriguing object.

Citation

“What Is Powering the Enigmatic He II Emitter Hebe: The First Stars or Black Holes?” Junehyoung Jeon et al 2026 ApJ 1006 27. doi:10.3847/1538-4357/ae7bea