AAS Nova

Starring in the Early Universe: Black Hole Stars and Little Red Dots

By on Features
Share:
NIRCam JADES image
Deep JWST imaging showing a field of distant galaxies including tiny red galaxies known as little red dots. [NASA, ESA, CSA, Brant Robertson (UC Santa Cruz), Ben Johnson (CfA), Sandro Tacchella (Cambridge), Marcia Rieke (University of Arizona), Daniel Eisenstein (CfA); Image Processing: Alyssa Pagan (STScI)]

JWST has uncovered a peculiar population of very distant objects known as “little red dots.” The mechanisms powering these objects’ peculiar properties — high luminosities, compact radii, and “V”-shaped spectra — remain uncertain. Could little red dots be the result of supermassive stars, galaxy mergers, or, as a recent study explores, black hole stars?

Direct-Collapse Black Holes and Little Red Dots

Since their discovery, little red dots have been the subject of many studies, but a complete explanation for their unique combination of properties remains elusive. Multiple studies have explored the growing population of peculiar dots, with some postulating that they are the result of stars thousands of times the mass of the Sun, supermassive stars entrenched in gas from a galaxy merger, or black holes embedded in dense accretion disks. 

Even more recently, studies have proposed that little red dots may be the remnants of direct-collapse black holes. In this scenario, a large cloud of gas in the early universe directly collapses into a stellar-mass black hole, and the remaining gas envelops the black hole, forming what is known as a quasi-star (or black hole star). Researchers have suggested that little red dots may be the late stage of this process when the black hole has accreted at least 10% of the total mass of the system. Direct comparisons between quasi-star evolutionary models and JWST observations of little red dots have yet to be explored but are necessary to confirm the potential of quasi-star origins.

Evolutionary Models of Quasi-Stars

Quasi-star HR diagram

Evolution of a theoretical quasi-star model on a Hertzsprung–Russell diagram. [Modified from Santarelli et al 2026]

Seeking to compare quasi-star evolutionary models to JWST observations of little red dots, Andrew D. Santarelli (Yale University) and collaborators developed a modeling framework to simulate quasi-star evolution. In this framework, a quasi-star is modeled as a black hole at the core of a massive star that accretes material from the stellar envelope over its lifetime. The authors computed models for a range of initial masses and tracked the evolution of the quasi-stars, predicting luminosities, temperatures, surface gravities, and lifetimes of these objects.

After a short initial phase of contraction lasting around 10,000 years, the quasi-star spends the rest of its approximately 20–40-million-year lifetime in the “late stage” as the central black hole continues to eat up the surrounding envelope. In the end, the quasi-star becomes a supermassive black hole a million times the mass of the Sun.

SED comparison of quasi-star + LRDs

Predicted spectral energy distributions of 1 million solar mass, late-stage quasi-stars both alone (black dashed line) and embedded in a host galaxy (solid blue line). Each panel compares the quasi-star to a little red dot observed by JWST. [Modified from Santarelli 2026]

From these models, the authors extracted synthetic spectral energy distributions for late-stage quasi-stars. In comparing the simulated quasi-star spectra to those of three observed little red dots, the authors found that the synthetic quasi-star spectra generally reproduce the main continuum features seen in all three of the little red dots. While the models do not account for specific emission lines, the continuum slopes of the ultraviolet and near-infrared parts of the spectral energy distributions that form the signature “V” shape generally agree with those seen in the three comparison little red dots.

Plausible Progenitors

The results of this study indicate that late-stage quasi-stars can naturally produce the defining continuum features of little red dot spectra. While further modeling is required to trace specific emission line features, the initial modeling presented in this study establishes quasi-stars as plausible progenitors of not only little red dots but also the universe’s first supermassive black holes. 

As the authors noted, the short lifetimes of quasi-stars shown in their models in conjunction with the observed number density of little red dots implies that a significant fraction of supermassive black holes formed through this mechanism. Continued observations of little red dots and advanced modeling of direct-collapse black holes will aid in determining if these peculiar dots are showing off the birth of supermassive black holes in the universe.

Citation

“Evolutionary Tracks and Spectral Properties of Quasi-stars and Their Correlation with Little Red Dots,” Andrew D. Santarelli et al 2026 ApJL 998 L4. doi:10.3847/2041-8213/ae3713