Among the discoveries JWST has made since its 2021 launch, “little red dots” are one of the most perplexing. Named for their compact size and red color, the origins of these distant galaxies remain unknown. A recent article explores some little red dots’ spectral energy distributions and local environments to better understand what may be lighting up these tiny torches.
Little Red Dot Dilemma
Along with their size and color, little red dots exhibit “V”-shaped spectral energy distributions (how they emit light across wavelengths), broad hydrogen emission lines, and no observed X-ray emission. These properties land them in an untapped parameter space with some similarities to both active galactic nuclei (AGNs) and stellar populations. Some previous investigations have suggested that little red dots contain AGNs, reddened by a dusty accretion disk scattering or blocking AGN light. Other studies have found that models for stellar populations can also fit certain little red dot spectra well.
Adding to the ambiguity, observations and theory predict AGNs to show broad spectral lines, which are present in little red dots — but if little red dots are AGNs, this implies a much higher density of AGNs in the early universe than previously predicted by ground-based surveys. Furthermore, AGNs are expected to emit in the X-ray and show photometric variability, but neither property has been detected definitively thus far for a little red dot. With a clear dilemma arising for the origins of little red dots, astronomers are still prodding at these curious sources.
AGN or Not?
Comparison of AGN versus non-AGN fits using the Bayesian information criterion (BIC). Positive values of ΔBIC favor a non-AGN fit, and ~70% of little red dots have positive ΔBIC. Click to enlarge. [Carranza-Escudero et al 2025]
Using a robust statistical analysis, the authors found that AGN models tend to “overfit” the data — with more free parameters, an AGN model can be tweaked in a way that may not actually be physical (e.g., fitting for extremely high dust extinction that would not be possible). Instead, models without AGN components appear to be more appropriate for about 70% of the little red dots in their sample, suggesting that these peculiar objects may have a significant star-forming component powering their emission.
Histograms for two redshift windows showing that little red dots (red) tend to be found in less dense environments than other galaxies (blue) in the same redshift window. Click to enlarge. [Carranza-Escudero et al 2025]
Lonely Neighborhoods
In addition to characterizing little red dots’ emission, the authors analyzed the local environments to compare to other galaxies at similar redshifts. From their analysis, they found that little red dots tend to be found in sparser environments, generally isolated from other galaxies. One explanation for this could be that little red dots in higher-density environments evolve past this peculiar stage faster, which is supported by observations of high-density environments accelerating the evolution of other galaxy types at similar redshifts. However, further investigation is required to better understand the connection between the local environment and little red dot properties.
More little red dots are yet to be discovered, and continued analysis of their emission and environments will uncover more intriguing characteristics. For now, it seems as though little red dots are still a mystery.
Citation
“Lonely Little Red Dots: Challenges to the Active Galactic Nucleus Nature of Little Red Dots through Their Clustering and Spectral Energy Distributions,” María Carranza-Escudero et al 2025 ApJL 989 L50. doi:10.3847/2041-8213/adf73d